10 and Under Rules Change

Earlier this month, the USTA adopted a fairly controversial new set of rules for 10 and under sanctioned competition. The rule change revolves around the use of the different Quickstart format balls and courts for sanctioned events in the 10 and under division. This hasn't exactly been the most well received decision the USTA has ever made. Here is a link to an interesting article from the Wall Street Journal detailing the change and some of the reaction to it:

Is Tennis Getting Too Soft? - Tom Perrotta

After I read this article, I thought there was a critical insight that wasn't well touched on. One of the biggest benefits to the use of the lower compression balls and reduced size courts is the idea of point construction. With so much of my job relating to this age division, I have gotten to see a fair amount of play first hand. One of the things that is lacking with the standard ball is the concept of how to construct a point. Kids are so focused on covering the entire full size court and hitting the ball that play lacks the development of strategy. By reducing the amount of court needing to be covered and slowing the ball down, it allows kids the opportunity to work on constructing shot patterns and utilizing strategy mid point. Perhaps if kids are coming off the court sore and tired in the new format, it's less about the balls and more about an issue with stroke mechanics and overhitting. The format also allows for the development of an all around game. Rather than just blasting the ball, kids are able to utilize drop shots, lobs, etc. It is also easier to come to net on a shorter court which leads to better development of vollies and net play.

Ultimately I understand some poeples' view that different isn't always better. But you know what, status quo isn't always better either. This format is still in the early stages of adoption when it comes to sanctioned play. Maybe, just like we encourage our kids to, we need to "play it out" before labeling it a bust or a success. I would love to hear feedback from you in the comments section if you have an opinion on the format change for 10 and under tennis.